Set theory and the continuum problem dover books on. Wittgenstein begins his theory of symbolism with the statement 2. Wittgensteins critique of set theory begins somewhat benignly in the tractatus, where he denounces logicism and says 6. From my reading, this is a pretty wild oversimplification of wittgenstein s position. Transfinite cardinals in set theory might seem to render the potential infinite defunct with the. Wittgenstein, linguistic rules, and contexf daniel whiting 7. In his tractatus logicophilosophicus ludwig wittgenstein 18891951 presents the concept of order in terms of a notational iteration that is completely logical but not part of logic. Wittgenstein on god, religion and theology joost w. We are familiar with various set theoretical paradoxes such as cantors paradox, buralifortis paradox, russells paradox, russellmyhill paradox and kaplans paradox. Wittgenstein also rids the physicist of the apparently unanswerable question of meaning of each single symbol. The mathematical theory of sets is both a foundation in some sense for classical mathematics and a branch of mathematics in its own right. Logic for him is not the foundation of mathematical concepts but rather a purely formal way of reflecting the world that at the minimum adds absolutely no content. Victor rodych, wittgensteins critique of set theory. The central component of language games is that they are uses of language, and language is used in multifarious ways.
He continues to influence current philosophical thought in topics as diverse as logic and language, perception and intention, ethics and religion, aesthetics and culture. Cantors first proof that infinite sets can have different. An example of wittgenstein s investigation of the logic of color concepts is his discussion of the relation between the concept of transparency and the concept of whiteness. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. That which has to be in common between the sentence and the fact cannot, so he contends, be itself in turn said in language. Pdf wittgenstein, language and philosophy of literature. About wittgensteins tractatus logicophilosophicus in 1921, ludwig josef johann wittgenstein 18891951 published a landmark book in philosophy, the tractatus logicophilosophicus. Find materials for this course in the pages linked along the left. Wittgenstein asserts that to use the same word is not meant to have the same meaning. Wittgensteins picture theory motivated by the sayingshowing distinction is here treated as an example of such general description. From the tractatuss picture theory of language hereafter lp we can strictly infer the two.
Cantors set theory was controversial at the start, but later became largely accepted. He explained that the main point is the theory of what can be expressed. Moore famously in the context of proposing to formulate a refution of philosophical skepticism concerning the existence of the external world pointed to his hand in a welllit lecture hall and uttered the sentence i know this is a hand. Pdf wittgenstein and the labyrinth of actual infinity. The main point of the tractatus is the theory of what can be expressed by propositions i. The book, now often just called the tractatus, puts forth a picture theory of the meaning of language. He wishes to impose a model that will simplify and order a seemingly chaotic set of uses of the concept of time. The place of saying and showing in wittgensteins tractatus. For example, x is good implies that one ought to have a favourable attitude towards it. In order to explain wittgensteins account of the reality of completed infinity in mathematics, a brief overview of cantors initial injection of the idea into settheory, its trajectory including the diagonal argument, the continuum. Wittgenstein s attempt to determine and express the boundary between meaningful expressions and senselessness is so general, i.
Click download or read online button to get culture and value wittgenstein pdf book now. Wittgensteins conception of infinity can be seen as continuing the tradition of the potential infinite that begins with aristotle. Wittgenstein s picture theory motivated by the sayingshowing distinction is here treated as an example of such general description. As kenneth kunen says, a set theory is the foundation of mathematics,a partly because a. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Coherence theories take truth to consist in relations of coherence among a set of beliefs. The problem of how to read the tractatus wittgenstein writes in the preface to his tractatus1 that the aim of the book is to set a limit to thought, or rather not to. The axioms of set theory of my title are the axioms of zermelofraenkel set theory, usually thought ofas arisingfromthe endeavourtoaxiomatise the cumulative hierarchy concept of set. To say what ludwig admired in goethe would almost be to say what he found remarkable or worthwhile in life, so many are the themes and attitudes from goethe that recur in his thought. It can, in his phraseology, only be shown,notsaid,forwhateverwemaysaywillstillneedtohavethesame structure.
David lewis, for instance, chose to define the null set as the fusion of all individuals, a definition which makes mathematics depend on the world. The theory of classes, wittgenstein says in the tractatus, is altogether superfluous in mathematics. On the whole, however, wittgenstein s influence, on the behavioral sciences, has remained marginal outside philosophy. Ludwig wittgenstein himself had absolute pitch, and his devotion to music remained vitally important to him throughout his life. How playing wittgensteinian languagegames can set us free. For wittgenstein aflirms that any analysis of linguistic form and meaning must be set in the context oflanguage use and must take into account. The two thinkers i shall consider who support this view are g. Anscombe an introduction to wittgensteins tractatus university of pennsylvania press, philadelphia 1971. One way of reading wittgenstein is to see him as a. Proceedings of the 30th international ludwig wittgenstein symposium in kirchberg, 2007. Culture and value wittgenstein pdf download ebook pdf, epub. Wittgensteins aesthetics first published fri jan 26, 2007. Wittgensteins picture theory of language as a key to.
Transfinite cardinals in set theory might seem to render the potential infinite defunct with the actual infinite now given mathematical legitimacy. Project gutenberg s tractatus logicophilosophicus, by ludwig wittgenstein this ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. German 26 april 1889 29 april 1951 was an austrianbritish philosopher who worked primarily in logic, the philosophy of mathematics, the philosophy of mind, and the philosophy of language. Ryan dawson, wittgenstein on set theory and the enormously. In particular, there have been objections to its use of infinite sets. Im looking at remarks on the foundation of mathematics right now, and hes basically making reasonable points that presage a lot of very relevant modern problems with set theory he is certainly not calling cantors work nonsense.
Ludwig wittgenstein for beginners prometheus unbound. Is it true that wittgenstein rejected set theory as. Project gutenbergs tractatus logicophilosophicus, by. He acknowledges the proofs as being valid in some sense. In order to explain wittgensteins account of the reality of completed infinity in mathematics, a brief overview of cantors initial injection of the idea into set theory, its trajectory including the diagonal argument, the continuum hypothesis and cantors theorem and the philosophic implications he attributed to it will be presented.
In order to explain wittgenstein s account of the reality of completed infinity in mathematics, a brief overview of cantors initial injection of the idea into set theory, its trajectory including the diagonal argument, the continuum. Wittgensteins picture theory of language and selfreference. A memoir oxford university press, oxford and new york 1984. Complex issues arise in set theory more than any other area of pure mathematics. The hidden settheoretical paradox of the tractatus. Although elementary set theory is wellknown and straightforward, the modern subject, axiomatic set theory, is both conceptually more di.
Wittgenstein suggested that a meaningful proposition pictured a state of affairs or atomic fact. Wittgenstein in general is difficult to interpret, and him on mathematics is even worse. Wittgenstein emphasizes that augustines problems are of his own making. The nal step in wittgensteins discussion of pictures is to note a connection between what can be pictured and what is possible. Wittgensteins critique of set theory rodych 2000 the. Set theory is also the most philosophical of all disciplines in mathematics. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. This is perhaps the most fundamental thesis of mr wittgenstein s theory. Wittgenstein s critique of set theory wittgenstein s critique of set theory rodych, victor 20000601 00. Ludwig wittgenstein represents a view oflinguistic phenomena which shows chomskys accounting of language acquisition to be mechanically impoverished and finally unsatisfactory. Hengstmengel the next best thing to being really inside christendom is to be really outside it. This relation became evident in wittgensteins picture relation theory wherein the use and invocation of a name also imply the invocation or appearance of the object related to that specific name.
Wittgensteins attempt to determine and express the boundary between meaningful expressions and senselessness is so general, i. Cantors theorem implies that there are sets having cardinality greater than the infinite cardinality of the set of natural numbers. Philosophy of set theory university of california, irvine. The big questions cannot be dodged, and students will not brook a flippant or easy answer. You may copy it, give it away or reuse it under the terms of the project gutenberg license included with this ebook or online at. In mathematical logic, the theory of infinite sets was first developed by georg cantor. I think that the closest he comes is a bit later in the text, when he says. Considered by some to be the greatest philosopher of the 20th century, ludwig wittgenstein played a central, if controversial, role in 20thcentury analytic philosophy. Wittgenstein says, we do not want to find a theory of color. Indeed, wittgenstein s discussion of irrationals is one with his critique of set theory, for, as he says, mathematics is ridden through and through with the pernicious idioms of set theory, such as the way people speak of a line as composed of points, when, in fact, a line is a law and isnt composed of anything at all pr 173. Wittgensteins critique of set theory, the southern journal. It was the maverick philosopher ludwig wittgenstein who coined the term languagegame. Wittgenstein on mathematical meaningfulness, decidability, and application, notre dame journal of. Transfinite cardinals in set theory might seem to render the potential infinite.
Set theory and the continuum problem has three parts. Wittgensteins idea is that whatever state of a airs can be pictured must also be possible 3. Wittgenstein is enabled to assert that propositions are all that follows from the totality of atomic propositions together with the fact that it is the totality of them. Having discussed wittgensteins picture theory of representation and his doctrine that all. The picture theory of language, also known as the picture theory of meaning, is a theory of linguistic reference and meaning articulated by ludwig wittgenstein in the tractatus logicophilosophicus. Wittgenstein s conception of infinity can be seen as continuing the tradition of the potential infinite that begins with aristotle. A central theme of wittgenstein s investigations rests on the concept of meaning. Wittgenstein introduces the term using simple examples, but intends it to be used for the many ways in which we use language. Wittgenstein on mathematical meaningfulness, decidability, and application, notre dame journal of formal logic 1997. Starting from the principles of symbolism and the relations which are necessary.
Brian mcguinness characterized goethes place in wittgenstein s thinking as follows. With this in mind, wittgenstein proposed the creation of a language that is reduced down to this nameobject relationship. Ludwig wittgenstein stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. As bishop berkeley said of philosophers, we first cast up a dust and then complain we cannot see. Our language and customs are fixed not by laws so much as by what wittgenstein calls forms of life, referring to the social contexts in which language is used. Project gutenbergs tractatus logicophilosophicus, by ludwig. Although ludwig wittgenstein is generally more known for his works on logic and on the nature of language, but throughout his philosophical journey he reflected extensively also on epistemic notions such as knowledge, belief, doubt, and certainty. In mathematics, the notion of a set is a primitive notion. The theory of classes, wittgenstein says in the tractatus, is altogether. Wittgensteins concept of language games 51 ewing is of the view that there is a hidden circularity as regards the meaning of the term intention. Both its foundational role and its particular mathematical features the centrality of.
In fact, there is another new possible set theoretical paradox hiding itself in wittgenstein s tractatus wittgenstein 1989. Logic and set theory to philosophy presumably the second edition 1927. In particular, social antiindividualism is still awaiting proper conversion into research strategies, just as is an adequate use of wittgenstein s conception of language games in linguistic pragmatics. Theories oftruth r a summary sketchl the object of this section is to sketch the main kinds of theories oftruth which have been proposed, and to indicate how they relate to each other. A picture, he says, is a model of the reality, and to the objects in the reality correspond the elements of the picture. Wittgenstein, ludwig internet encyclopedia of philosophy.
Wittgenstein on meaning and use james conant, university of pittsburgh g. That is not to label wittgenstein as a behaviorist. Opposing the metaphysical view are cora diamond and james conant who take the passages on nonsense literally. The place of saying and showing in wittgensteins tractatus and some later works ma r t i n pu l i d o i n a letter to bertrand russell, wittgenstein complained that the british philosopher did not understand the main message of the tractatus. Although this work has become a thoroughly standard fixture of classical set theory, it has been criticized in several areas by mathematicians and philosophers. Though floyd and putnam do not clearly distinguish the two tasks, they also argue for the floydputnam thesis, namely, that in the 1930s wittgenstein had a particular correct understanding of godels first incompleteness theorem. Brian mcguinness characterized goethes place in wittgensteins thinking as follows. Wittgensteins critique of set theory, the southern. He contended that words acquire meaning by their use, and wanted to see how their use was tied up with the social practices of which they are a part.
In order to explain wittgenstein s account of the reality of completed infinity in mathematics, a brief overview of cantors initial injection of the idea into set theory, its trajectory including the diagonal argument, the continuum hypothesis and cantors theorem and the philosophic implications he attributed to it will be presented. The picture theory of representation phil 43904 je speaks november 6, 2007. Jun 01, 2000 wittgensteins critique of set theory wittgensteins critique of set theory rodych, victor 20000601 00. His most recent publications include wittgensteins inversion of godels theorem erkenntnis 1999, wittgenstein on irrationals and algorithmic decidability, synthese 1999. Subsequent sections will discuss some theories in detail. Whether one views this as gesturing at a theoryof meaning, or as aiming primarily to dissuade us from certain misconceptions oflanguage. Wittgenstein never says explicitly what he has in mind here.
Wittgenstein develops this discussion of games into the key notion of a languagegame. This is connected with the fact that the generality which we need in mathematics is not the accidental one. Wittgensteins tractatus logicophilosophicus, whether or not it prove to give the ultimate truth on the matters with which it deals, certainly deserves, by its breadth and scope and profundity, to be considered an important event in the philosophical world. According to ludwig wittgensteins tractatus logicophilosophicus, the form shared by language and the world cannot be said through language, but rather shows itself in language. The meaning of a bishop in a game of chess is not attained by finding out the material of which the piece is made. The picture theory of representation university of notre dame. There are other conceptions of set, but although they have genuine mathematical interest they are not our concern here. Wittgenstein on logical form and the nature of philosophy.
1014 1504 1508 1036 1138 1318 227 654 1044 1359 569 102 1264 882 638 1064 662 972 404 382 190 1060 325 710 945 1499 528 203 923 1089 185 1180 1006 519 1190 1364 1120