Katya feder is a research scientist and project coordinator for health canadas community noise and health study. People living near wind farms face a greater risk of suffering health complaints caused by the lowfrequency noise generated by turbines, a groundbreaking study has found. The area of wind energy is a rapidly evolving field and an intensive research and development has taken place in the last few years. Dr hanning, a founder of the british sleep society, is a leading sleep clinician and researcher. Both onshore and offshore wind farms are discussed. When individuals expect a feature of their environment or. The wind turbine noise and health study is a landmark study and the most comprehensive of its kind. Who investigates health effects of wind turbine noise. Health canada publishes findings from wind turbine noise.
The dubious science of windturbine syndrome the atlantic. In 1981, physicist neil kelley and colleagues reported their investigation of complaints from residents living within 3 kilometers of an experimental 2megawatt downwind twoblade wind turbine in boone, north carolina, which had begun operation in the fall of 1979. Environmental impact of wind powerarchive 3 wikipedia. He has made presentations regarding wind turbine noise to community groups, the international world wind. Canada to study health effects of wind turbine noise. This book presents the most relevant results of these projects. But as this article in the british medical journal lancet details. Background wind turbine noise exposure and suspected healthrelated effects thereof have attracted substantial attention. Health effects of noise from large wind turbines wind. Christopher d hanning, honorary consultant in sleep medicine, sleep disorders service, university hospitals of leicester, leicester general hospital, leicester le5 4pw, uk and alun evans, professor emeritus, centre for public health, queens university of belfast, institute of. Risk of harm and industrial wind energy facilities, physicians as health advocates a commentary by carmen krogh, bscpharm, january, 20 any errors or omissions are unintended 4 some report a feeling of being dismisseddiscounted.
Tracing the history and development of medical journals, especially. The european commission has therefore funded a number of research projects in the field of wind turbine noise within the joule program. Bad science behind the wind turbine noise guidelines wind. Journal of epidemiology and community health, 558, 588594. Risk of harm 1 and industrial wind energy facilities. In 1981, physicist neil kelley and colleagues reported their investigation of complaints from residents living within 3 kilometers of an experimental 2megawatt downwind twoblade wind turbine in boone, north carolina, which had begun. Effects of industrial wind turbine noise on sleep and. Only articles published in english, german or scandinavian. The controversy over wind turbine noise has been raging in australia for more than two years. Nov 11, 2014 the evidence also shows that wind turbine noise annoyance is more strongly related to other negative attitudes about wind turbines, particularly the visual impact of wind turbines on the land scape, than to sound level 7, 49.
Evans 2012 wind turbine noise, ritish medical journal 344, e1527. Association between wind turbine noise and physical health effects 73. Noise levels and noise perception from small and micro. To better understand causes and effects of wind turbine wt noise, this study combined the methodology of stress psychology with noise measurement to an integrated approach.
Exposure response relationship for transportation noise. What is the wind the wind turbine noise and health study. Part of an experiment in the 1960s, the enormous device was designed to explore. A comprehensive guide to wind farm noise prediction, measurement, assessment, control and effects on people wind farm noise covers all aspects associated with the generation, measurement, propagation, regulation and adverse health effects of noise produced by large horizontalaxis wind turbines of the type used in wind farms. Acoustics free fulltext recent advances in wind turbine noise. Both the methodology used and the results are significant contributions to the global knowledge base and examples of innovative, leadingedge research. Recent developments in horizontalaxis wind turbine noise research are. Investigation, understanding and reduction of noise from wind turbines is a necessary progression in the development of this sector of renewable energy. Campaigners call on doctors to monitor impact of wind turbines. A dynamo mounted on an 80 m tower is driven through a gear train by blades as long as 45 m, and this generates both gear train noise and aerodynamic noise as the blades pass through the air, causing vortices to be shed from the edges.
Wind turbine noise 2017 international conferences on. Wind turbine noise is intermittent in intensity wind changes direction, and is unlike other annoyance noise. Review of the evidence on the response to amplitude modulation am from wind turbines, with recommendations on control through the use of a planning condition. Christopher d hanning, honorary consultant in sleep medicine, sleep disorders service, university hospitals of leicester, leicester general hospital, leicester le5 4pw, uk and alun evans, professor emeritus, centre belfast, institute of clinical science b, belfast, uk. There can be no reasonable doubt that industrial wind turbines whether singly or in groups wind farms generate sufficient noise to disturb the sleep and impair the health of. Wind power wind power was the first of the second generation renewables to become cheaper than coal, and as a result its popularity has absolutely exploded in the last 15 years. Health canadas wind turbine noise and health study expert. Weir, dr james turbines and the health risk scottish.
Wind turbine noise christopher d hanning and alun evans british medical journal, bm j2 012. Industrial wind turbine noise is more annoying than road, rail, and aircraft noise, for the same sound pressure, presumably due to its impulsive character. Nov 11, 2014 the worldwide expansion of wind energy has met with opposition based on concerns that the infrasound generated by wind turbines causes health problems in nearby residents. Wind power generation has become an accepted industry in canada, with large scale wind farms involving 20 or more wind turbines now operating in most provinces. Case studies that have convinced me that industrial wind. Governments have recently paid much attention to the effects of environmental noise on sleep duration and quality, and to how to reduce such noise. Research design and noise exposure assessment, 2012 9.
This chapter gives a few examples of sources of noise in the community broadly defined. Health canada wind turbine noise and health study any errors or omissions contained within this submission are unintentional july 30, 2012 new brunswick, canada premier and ministries a number, april 3, 2012 municipal council, april 3, 2012 nova scotia, canada ministers, a number, may 16, 2012 kings county, february, 20, 2012. Assessments assessments in progress wind turbine noise and human health the expert panel on wind turbine noise and human health hugh w. By relating the sound measurements and peoples reactions in a rigorous manner the much debated wind turbine syndrome can be systematically investigated. It should be required reading for all planners considering wind farms. During her 3 year visiting fellowship 20082010 in the health effects and assessment division of health canada, she was the lead investigator mp3 player user listening habits in children.
The new organisation cites a recent editorial in the british medical journal on the health implications associated with the noise of wind turbines for people who live close by. It is low frequency sound, and cannot be blocked with ear plugs and ear protectors. Pedersen e, waye k 2007 wind turbine noise, annoyance and selfreported health and wellbeing in different living environments. Results of the health canada wind turbine noise and health. Wind turbine noise bmj editorial wind energy impacts. Some researchers show this as a causal relationship. Christopher d hanning, honorary consultant in sleep medicine, sleep disorders service, university hospitals of leicester, leicester general hospital, leicester le5 4pw. The results of more recent studies that investigated wind turbine noise with respect to potential human health effects are. Christopher d hanning, honorary consultant in sleep medicine, sleep disorders service, university hospitals of leicester, leicester general hospital, leicester le5 4pw, uk. Health aspects associated with wind turbine noiseresults from three. However, turbines ie wind generate electromagnetic waves in the form of poor power quality dirty electricity and ground current. Thus, rhetoric that creates health concerns about wind turbine sound, and presents a negative view of wind farms, is. Link to publication record in queens university belfast research portal general rights.
Mar 15, 2018 when sound makes you sick by patrick j. The expert panel on wind turbine noise and human health. The association between wind turbines and health effects is highly debated. This novel work highlighted the role of negative expectations and. Oct 20, 2012 curious distribution for wind turbine sickness. Worlds largest wind farm study finds sleep disturbances. Ambient baseline sound levels will be a function of such things as local traffic. Christopher hanning, british medical journal, march 2012 bmj 2012. The evidence for adequate sleep as a prerequisite for human health, particularly child health, is overwhelming. Jun 19, 2017 in his 1973 book supernature, the scientist and adventurer lyall watson tells the story of a sixfootlong whistle.
Tobacco industry efforts at discrediting scientific knowledge of environmental tobacco smoke. While no direct effects of wind turbine noise on sleep. British medical journal queens university belfast research portal. Revision of who environmental noise guidelines for the. These recommendations are based on our lack of confidence in the institute of acoustics noise working group. Christopher hanning, bsc, mb, bs, mrcs, lrcp, frca, md is an. Her detailed recording of the harm caused by wind turbine noise will lay firm foundations for future research. Launched in 2012, in collaboration with statistics canada, this study explored the relationship between exposure to wind turbine noise and the health effects reported by, and measured in, people living near wind turbines. From this basis and with an average annual production of wind turbine of up to 4,000 mwh troen and petersem 1991, an energy payback time of 0. British medical journal acknowledges health impacts of wind farms. The work in this paper summarises findings from a project that measured the noise levels from small and micro turbines from a number of sites close to residents and workers from whom responses to noise were sought. Response to noise from modern wind farms in the netherlands 2010 salt, a.
It has been known since the early 1980s that noise from large wind turbines can adversely affect human health. Apr 15, 2014 the image on the bottom half of this slide comes from an ad placed in a victorian rural newspaper by an antiwind group in 2009 the year the term wind turbine syndrome was coined. Jun 18, 2014 campaigners are urging doctors to join the fight against windfarms. Sep 14, 2012 turbine noise and deficiencies in the regulation of this noise. Wind health impacts dismissed in court energy and policy. Various symptoms such as sleeprelated problems, headache, tinnitus and vertigo have been described by subjects suspected of having been exposed to wind turbine noise. A recent publication, in the british medical journal, cited that reducing air pollution can. In this longitudinal study, residents of a wind farm in lower saxony were interviewed on two occasions 2012, 2014 and given the opportunity to use audio equipment to. A large body of evidence now exists to suggest that wind turbines disturb sleep and impair health at distances and external noise levels that are permitted in most jurisdictions, including the united kingdom. The prevalence of residents reporting that they were very or extremely annoyed by wind turbine noise increased from 2. Curious distribution for wind turbine sickness the science. The evidence also shows that wind turbine noise annoyance is more strongly related to other negative attitudes about wind turbines, particularly the visual impact of wind turbines on the land scape, than to sound level 7, 49. Some people apparently dont have ears sensitive enough to hear it, but some of us especially children, do. Energies free fulltext wind turbine blade design html.
Wind turbine noise and human health hearing health matters. The impact of wind turbine noise on health and wellbeing has not yet been wellestablished and remains under. Review of the evidence on the response to amplitude. Pedersen e, waye kp, perception and annoyance due to wind turbine noisea doseresponse relationship. Today, canada has over 1,000 mw of installed wind energy capacity, and the federal government and some provincial. The controversy over windturbine noise has been raging in australia for more than two years. Kiger mar 15, 2018 medical and scientific researchers have found increasing evidence that sound including frequencies that cannot be heard by humans is linked to a variety of health problems, including hypertension, heart disease and strokes. The author of the current editorial wind turbine noises deserves sincere.
Wearable technologies for developing sleep and circadian biomarkers. Of the many other claimed health effects of wind turbine noise. A comprehensive guide to wind farm noise prediction, measurement, assessment, control and effects on people. Hanning discussed turbine noise, sleep disturbance, and consequent health effects. What wind turbine syndrome tells us about the future of. The council of canadian academies issued its report understanding the evidence. British columbia has many excellent locations for wind farms, but wind power expansion has been slow compared to some other provinces and some other countries. Christopher d hanning and alun evans british medical journal, bmj. In this paper, we argue that health complaints are more likely to be explained by the nocebo response, whereby adverse effects are generated by negative expectations. Health canada published findings from the wind turbine noise and health study. Conference warns health effects of wind turbines should be taken seriously. This is supported by the report on wind turbine noise 34, which. Pdf wind turbine incidentcomplaint reports in ontario. Health effects related to wind turbine noise exposure.
Noise, health from the prestigous british medical journal. Ottawa, canada, july 12, 2012 ens canadian health and statistics agencies are planning to explore the impact of wind turbine noise on the health of people living near wind power developments. Wind warning to world health organizationeurope turbine. Therefore, this book aims to provide an uptodate comprehensive overview of the current status in the field to the research community. A panel of experts from canada and other countries worldwide was set up to evaluate the evidence linking health impacts of wind turbine noise and to identify research gaps as well.
The research works presented in this book are divided into three main groups. The results of more recent studies that investigated wind turbine noise with respect to potential human health effects are summarized below in chronological order. Wind turbine noise, sleep and health page 6 of 46 2. These symptoms have been attributed to the pressure sound waves did wind turbines generate in the form of noise and infrasound. In his 1973 book supernature, the scientist and adventurer lyall watson tells the story of a sixfootlong whistle. The link between health complaints and wind turbines. In 1889, an article in the british medical journal warned that spending long periods on the telephone could cause nervous excitability, with buzzing noises in the ear, giddiness, and neuralgic. Noise from aircraft operations is an important source of community noise, and three examples are given. Wind turbine noise from the prestigous british medical journal shortly after wind turbines began to be erected close to housing, complaints emerged of adverse effects on health. Much of the fight has focused on the noise generated by the waubra wind project in the state of. There is more limited and conflicting evidence that shows association or a causal relationship between wind.
Wind farm noise covers all aspects associated with the generation, measurement, propagation, regulation and adverse health effects of noise produced by large horizontalaxis wind turbines of the type used in wind farms the book begins with a brief history of wind turbine. The call follows claims there is a growing body of international evidence about human and animal health being damaged by turbines. Review of studies and literature relating to wind turbines. Wind turbine noise, british medical journal, 3 oct 12 authors. Wind turbine noise dick bowdler and geoff leventhall multisciencepublishing co. Health aspects associated with wind turbine noiseresults.
Following the success of the workshops on resource assessment brussels, may 2011 and postconstruction assessment lyon, july 2012, eweas third technology workshop, organised in response to requests from ewea members, provided a unique, industryonly forum at which 160 industry. The pattern of complaints about australian wind farms does. The studies considered pierponts book along with other published literature. The book addresses all relevant aspects of wind turbine noise, namely. Davies associate professor of occupational and environmental health, school of population and public health, university of british columbia vancouver, bc. In the effort of being more open and transparent, the. This caused them additional pain, hurt, grief and a sense of being doubted. Wind turbine noise, british medical journal, 3 oct 12. Conference warns health effects of wind turbines should be. Understanding stress effects of wind turbine noise the. The book begins with a brief history of wind turbine development and.
138 634 1155 916 1039 1333 699 619 195 524 1219 300 1280 756 976 888 371 628 393 609 1381 182 1187 1113 1540 1036 886 1220 859 650 976 263 1202 1231 1040 1245 464 276 407 106 909 351 680 845 1367 758 1418 585